I applied BV 511 on my left arm and Angels Share on my right arm for direct comparison and it doesn't come close to the original. There is a distant and minimal resemblance, but it is completely unsatisfactory. The original ist warm, rich, spicy, woody, sweet, strong, nutty and you can smell the individual scents, especially the Cognac. It is simply balanced and harmonious. Unfortunately this perfume can't keep up. It's even a little soapy, wich gets better with time, but I find it annoying. Longevity an sillage are also weak. It's not a bad scent, but If you're expecting AS, you won't be happy with it. Unfortunately no recommendation.